Bureau of Prisons: Improvements Needed in Bureau of Prisons' Monitoring and Evaluation of Impact of Segregated Housing
Highlights
What GAO Found
The overall number of inmates in the Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) three main types of segregated housing units--Special Housing Units (SHU), Special Management Units (SMU), and Administrative Maximum (ADX)--increased at a faster rate than the general inmate population. Inmates may be placed in SHUs for administrative reasons, such as pending transfer to another prison, and for disciplinary reasons, such as violating prison rules; SMUs, a four-phased program in which inmates can progress from more to less restrictive conditions; or ADX, for inmates that require the highest level of security. From fiscal year 2008 through February 2013, the total inmate population in segregated housing units increased approximately 17 percent--from 10,659 to 12,460 inmates. By comparison, the total inmate population in BOP facilities increased by about 6 percent during this period.
BOP has a mechanism to centrally monitor segregated housing, but the degree of monitoring varies by unit type and GAO found incomplete documentation of monitoring at select prisons. BOP headquarters lacks the same degree of oversight of ADX-specific conditions of confinement compared with SHUs and SMUs partly because ADX policies are monitored locally by ADX officials. Developing specific requirements for ADX could provide BOP with additional assurance that inmates held at ADX are afforded their minimum conditions of confinement and procedural protections. According to a selection of monitoring reports and inmate case files, GAO also identified documentation concerns related to conditions of confinement and procedural protections, such as ensuring that inmates received all their meals and exercise as required. According to BOP officials, in December 2012, all SHUs and SMUs began using a new software program that could improve the ability to document conditions of confinement in SHUs and SMUs. However, BOP officials acknowledged the recently implemented software program may not address all the deficiencies GAO identified. Since BOP could not provide evidence that it addressed the documentation deficiencies, GAO cannot determine if it will mitigate the documentation concerns. BOP expects to complete a review of the new software program by approximately September 30, 2013, which should help determine the extent to which the software program addresses documentation deficiencies GAO identified.
BOP has not assessed the impact of segregated housing on institutional safety or the impacts of long-term segregation on inmates. In January 2013, BOP authorized a study of segregated housing; however, it is unclear to what extent the study will assess the extent to which segregated housing units contribute to institutional safety. As of January 2013, BOP is considering conducting mental health case reviews for inmates held in SHUs or ADX for more than 12 continuous months. However, without an assessment of the impact of segregation on institutional safety or study of the long-term impact of segregated housing on inmates, BOP cannot determine the extent to which segregated housing achieves its stated purpose to protect inmates, staff and the general public.
Why GAO Did This Study
BOP confines about 7 percent of its 217,000 inmates in segregated housing units for about 23 hours a day. Inmates are held in SHUs, SMUs, and ADX. GAO was asked to review BOP's segregated housing unit practices. This report addresses, among other things: (1) the trends in BOP's segregated housing population, (2) the extent to which BOP centrally monitors how prisons apply segregated housing policies, and (3) the extent to which BOP assessed the impact of segregated housing on institutional safety and inmates. GAO analyzed BOP's policies for compliance and analyzed population trends from fiscal year 2008 through February 2013. GAO visited six federal prisons selected for different segregated housing units and security levels, and reviewed 61 inmate case files and 45 monitoring reports. The results are not generalizable, but provide information on segregated housing units.
Recommendations
GAO recommends that BOP (1) develop ADX-specific monitoring requirements; (2) develop a plan that clarifies how BOP will address documentation concerns GAO identified, through the new software program; (3) ensure that any current study to assess segregated housing also includes reviews of its impact on institutional safety; and (4) assess the impact of long-term segregation. BOP agreed with these recommendations and reported it would take actions to address them.
Recommendations for Executive Action
| Agency Affected | Recommendation | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Bureau of Prisons | To improve BOP's ability to centrally oversee the implementation of segregated housing policies, the Director of the Bureau of Prisons should develop ADX-specific monitoring requirements. | We found that the Bureau of Prisons (BOP) could improve oversight of the implementation of segregated housing policies at its most restrictive segregated prison, the Administrative Maximum Facility (ADX). As a result, we recommended that BOP develop ADX-specific monitoring requirements to provide BOP with additional assurance that inmates held at ADX are given their procedural protections in accordance with BOP policies. In June 2014, BOP developed ADX-specific monitoring requirements that were added to the Correctional Services Guidelines. Specifically, the Correctional Services Guidelines includes ADX-specific monitoring of conditions of confinement, such as exercise, telephone and... visitation. BOP also improved oversight of ADX procedures by including a requirement to review a sample of psychological assessments of inmates placed in ADX, as well as inmates who are in the Control Unit. Overall, BOP took steps to address and include ADX-specific monitoring requirements that are consistent with our recommendation. By developing requirements to centrally monitor policies specific to ADX, BOP can have more assurance that staff consistently follow ADX-specific policies to the same degree that these requirements are followed for other segregated housing units.
View More |
| Bureau of Prisons | To improve BOP's ability to centrally oversee the implementation of segregated housing policies, the Director of the Bureau of Prisons should develop a plan that clarifies the objectives and goals of the new software program, with time frames and milestones, and other means, that explains the extent to which the software program will address documentation concerns we identified. | In May 2013, we found that Bureau of Prisons (BOP) officials were not consistently documenting that segregated housing unit inmates' conditions of confinement, such as food and exercise privileges, were being met. According to BOP officials, in December 2012, all special housing units (SHU) and special management units (SMU)--which are segregated housing units used by BOP--began using a new software program that could improve the ability to document conditions of confinement in SHUs and SMUs. However, BOP officials acknowledged that the recently implemented software program may not address all the deficiencies GAO identified. As a result, we recommended that BOP develop a plan that...
|
| Bureau of Prisons | To ensure that BOP's use of segregated housing furthers BOP's goal to confine inmates in a humane manner and contributes to institutional safety without having a detrimental impact on inmates held there for long periods of time, the Director of the Bureau of Prisons should ensure that any current study to assess segregated housing units also includes an assessment of the extent that segregated housing contributes to institutional safety, and consider key practices that include local and state efforts to reduce reliance on and the number of inmates held in segregated housing. | In May 2013, we found that BOP authorized a study of segregated housing in January 2013; however, the extent to which the study would assess the impact of segregated housing on institutional safety was unclear. As a result, we recommended that BOP ensure that any current study to assess segregated housing units also include an assessment of the extent that segregated housing contributes to institutional safety, and consider key practices that include local and state efforts to reduce their reliance on and number of inmates held in segregated housing. In May 2014, BOP officials reported that through a competitive procurement process, BOP's National Institute of Corrections selected an...
|
| Bureau of Prisons | To ensure that BOP's use of segregated housing furthers BOP's goal to confine inmates in a humane manner and contributes to institutional safety without having a detrimental impact on inmates held there for long periods of time, the Director of the Bureau of Prisons should assess the impact of long-term segregation on inmates in SHUs, SMUs, and ADX. | We found that BOP had not evaluated the impact of long-term segregation on inmates. As a result, we recommended that BOP assess the impact of long-term segregation on inmates held in Special Housing Units (SHU), Special Management Units (SMU), and Administrative Maximum (ADX). In May 2014, BOP reported that they developed an expanded mental health screening tool--including a record review, behavioral observations, and a private clinical review--that would help assess the impact of long-term segregation on inmates. This screening tool, along with new policy on the Treatment and Care of Inmates with Mental Illness issued May 1, 2014, is to be used by BOP Psychology Services staff to assess...
|