Wind Energy: Additional Actions Could Help Ensure Effective Use of Federal Financial Support
Highlights
What GAO Found
GAO identified 82 federal wind-related initiatives, with a variety of key characteristics, implemented by nine agencies in fiscal year 2011. Five agencies--the Departments of Energy (DOE), the Interior, Agriculture (USDA), Commerce, and the Treasury--collectively implemented 73 of the initiatives. The 82 initiatives incurred about $2.9 billion in wind-related obligations and provided estimated wind-related tax subsidies totaling at least $1.1 billion in fiscal year 2011, although complete data on wind-related tax subsidies were not available. Initiatives supporting deployment of wind facilities, such as those financing their construction or use, constituted the majority of initiatives and accounted for nearly all obligations and estimated tax subsidies related to wind in fiscal year 2011. In particular, a tax expenditure and a grant initiative, both administered by Treasury, accounted for nearly all federal financial support for wind energy.
The 82 wind-related initiatives GAO identified were fragmented across agencies, most had overlapping characteristics, and several that financed deployment of wind facilities provided some duplicative financial support. The 82 initiatives were fragmented because they were implemented across nine agencies, and 68 overlapped with at least one other initiative because of shared characteristics. About half of all initiatives reported formal coordination. Such coordination can, in principle, reduce the risk of unnecessary duplication and improve the effectiveness of federal efforts. However, GAO identified 7 initiatives that have provided duplicative support--financial support from multiple initiatives to the same recipient for deployment of a single project. Specifically, wind project developers have in many cases combined the support of more than 1 Treasury initiative and, in some cases, have received additional support from smaller grant or loan guarantee programs at DOE or USDA. GAO also identified 3 other initiatives that did not fund any wind projects in fiscal year 2011 but that could, based on their eligibility criteria, be combined with 1 or more initiatives to provide duplicative support. Of the 10 initiatives, those at Treasury accounted for over 95 percent of the federal financial support for wind in fiscal year 2011.
Agencies implementing the 10 initiatives allocate support to projects on the basis of the initiatives' goals or eligibility criteria, but the extent to which applicant financial need is considered is unclear. DOE and USDA--which have some discretion over the projects they support through their initiatives--allocate support based on projects' ability to meet initiative goals such as reducing emissions or benefitting rural communities, as well as other criteria. Both agencies also consider applicant need for the support of some initiatives, according to officials. However, GAO found that neither agency documents assessments of applicant need; therefore the extent to which they use such assessments to determine how much support to provide is unclear. Unlike DOE and USDA, Treasury generally supports projects based on the tax code's eligibility criteria and does not have discretion to allocate support to projects based on need. While the support of these initiatives may be necessary in many cases for wind projects to be built, because agencies do not document assessments of need, it is unclear, in some cases, if the entire amount of federal support provided was necessary. Federal support in excess of what is needed to induce projects to be built could instead be used to induce other projects to be built or simply withheld, thereby reducing federal expenditures.
Why GAO Did This Study
Wind energy has been the fastest growing source of U.S. electric power generation in recent years. The increase in federal funding for wind technologies and involvement of multiple agencies has raised questions about fragmented, overlapping, or duplicative federal support.
In this report, GAO examines federal wind-related initiatives--programs or groups of agency activities that promoted wind energy through a specific emphasis or focus. GAO (1) identifies wind-related initiatives implemented by federal agencies in fiscal year 2011 and their key characteristics; (2) assesses the extent of fragmentation, overlap, and duplication, if any, among these initiatives, and the extent to which they were coordinated; and (3) examines how agencies allocate support to projects through their initiatives and the extent to which they assess applicant need for support. GAO sent a questionnaire to agencies to identify wind-related initiatives and to obtain data on their characteristics; potential for fragmentation, overlap, or duplication; and related coordination. GAO also reviewed studies of the initiatives and interviewed agency officials and financial professionals.
Recommendations
GAO recommends that to the extent possible within their statutory authority DOE and USDA formally assess and document whether the federal financial support of their initiatives is needed for applicants' wind projects to be built. DOE agreed with the recommendation and USDA generally concurred with the findings related to its initiatives.
Recommendations for Executive Action
| Agency Affected | Recommendation | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Department of Agriculture | To support federal agencies' efforts to effectively allocate resources among wind projects, the Secretaries of Energy and Agriculture, to the extent possible within their statutory authority, should formally assess and document whether the incremental financial support of their initiatives is needed in order for applicants' projects to be built and take this information into account in determining whether, or how much, support to provide. Such assessments could include, for example, information on the investors' and developers' projected rates of return on these projects, or documentation of applicants' inability to secure private financing for projects. In addition, such assessments should consider the financial support available or provided to projects from other federal sources including tax expenditures and, to the extent practical, from state sources. In the event agencies lack discretion to consider this information in determining what financial support to provide, they may want to report this limitation to Congress. |
GAO recommended in March 2013 that the Department of Agriculture (USDA) take action to the extent possible within its statutory authority to help ensure effective use of financial support from several wind energy initiatives, which GAO found provided duplicative support that may not have been needed in all cases for projects to be built. Specifically, GAO recommended USDA formally assess and document whether its incremental financial support is needed for applicants' projects to be built, and take this information into account in determining whether, or how much, support to provide. In the event USDA lacks discretion to consider this information in determining what financial support to provide, GAO suggested the agency report this limitation to Congress. In September 2013, USDA reported to Congress that determinations regarding whether to provide financial support, and if so how much, to applicants are established in the statutes governing its initiatives and that, under existing law, USDA has neither the discretion nor program purpose to formally assess applicant need in making these determinations.
|
| Department of Energy | To support federal agencies' efforts to effectively allocate resources among wind projects, the Secretaries of Energy and Agriculture, to the extent possible within their statutory authority, should formally assess and document whether the incremental financial support of their initiatives is needed in order for applicants' projects to be built and take this information into account in determining whether, or how much, support to provide. Such assessments could include, for example, information on the investors' and developers' projected rates of return on these projects, or documentation of applicants' inability to secure private financing for projects. In addition, such assessments should consider the financial support available or provided to projects from other federal sources including tax expenditures and, to the extent practical, from state sources. In the event agencies lack discretion to consider this information in determining what financial support to provide, they may want to report this limitation to Congress. |
GAO recommended in March 2013 that the Department of Energy (DOE) take action to help ensure effective use of financial support from wind energy initiatives that GAO found provided duplicative support that may not have been needed in all cases for projects to be built. Specifically, GAO recommended DOE formally assess and document whether its incremental financial support is needed in order for applicants' projects to be built, and take this information into account in determining whether, or how much, support to provide. With respect to a DOE initiative that GAO found provided support that may not have been needed for some projects to be built, DOE's most recent solicitation for applications required that applicants provide specific information to allow DOE to evaluate whether the applicants' projects could be fully financed without the initiative's incremental support. DOE also reported that those responsible for evaluating the information submitted by applicants would document the results of their evaluations.
|