Nuclear Regulatory Commission:
Oversight of Underground Piping Systems Commensurate with Risk, but Proactive Measures Could Help Address Future Leaks
GAO-11-563: Published: Jun 3, 2011. Publicly Released: Jun 21, 2011.
All U.S. nuclear power plant sites have had some groundwater contamination from radioactive leaks, and some of these leaks came from underground piping systems. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) regulates nuclear power plants to protect public health and the environment from radiation hazards. GAO was asked to (1) determine experts' opinions on the impacts, if any, of underground piping system leaks on public health and the environment; (2) assess NRC requirements of licensees for inspecting these systems and monitoring and reporting on leaks; (3) identify actions the nuclear power industry, licensees, and NRC have taken in response to leaks; and (4) identify additional NRC requirements, if any, that key stakeholders think could help prevent, detect, and disclose leaks. GAO convened expert discussion groups through the National Academy of Sciences and asked experts to review three case studies, analyzed documents, visited seven plant sites and two NRC regional offices, and interviewed stakeholders.
While experts in our public health discussion group generally agreed that radioactive leaks at the three nuclear power plants in our case studies of actual events had no discernible impact on the public's health, these experts noted that additional information could enhance the identification of the leaks and the characterization of their impacts. The experts in our environmental impact discussion group concluded that environmental resources beyond the plant site have not been impacted discernibly, but that on-site contamination could affect plant decommissioning; for example, the licensee may have to conduct costly remediation to meet NRC regulations for unrestricted release of the site. Experts also identified the need for licensees to transparently report monitoring data and for licensees' groundwater monitoring programs to be independently reviewed. NRC inspection requirements focus on ensuring the functionality of underground piping systems that are essential for both the safe operation and the shutdown of plants rather than providing information about the condition of the underground piping systems. In addition, NRC's groundwater monitoring requirements generally focus on monitoring off-site locations, where a member of the public could be exposed to radiation, but not on onsite groundwater monitoring, which can improve the likelihood that leaks will be detected before they migrate off-site. In response to leaks, the nuclear power industry has implemented two voluntary initiatives to increase public confidence in plant safety. The first initiative was intended to improve on-site groundwater monitoring to promptly detect leaks. The second was intended to provide reasonable assurance of underground piping systems' structural and leaktight integrity. Licensees' responses to detected leaks have varied, ranging from repairing the leak source and documenting the leak's extent, to performing extensive mitigation. In addition, NRC has assessed its regulatory framework for, and oversight of, inspection of underground piping systems and groundwater monitoring. Based on the low risk posed by spills to date, NRC determined that no further regulations are needed at this time but has committed to such actions as gathering information on underground piping leak trends and reviewing codes and standards for underground piping. Key stakeholders identified additional NRC requirements that they thought could help prevent, detect, and disclose leaks. Some saw a need for NRC to require licensees to inspect the structural integrity of underground piping using techniques used in the oil and gas industry, while noting the challenges to applying such techniques at nuclear power plants. Industry is undertaking research to overcome these challenges. Stakeholders also noted that NRC should enhance its on-site groundwater monitoring requirements to promptly detect leaks and minimize their impacts. Finally, stakeholders said that NRC should require licensees to provide leak information in a more timely fashion and should make that information more accessible to the public. GAO recommends that NRC periodically assess the effectiveness of the groundwater initiative and determine whether structural integrity tests should be included in licensee inspection requirements, when they become feasible, based on industry research. NRC stated it agrees with the report and recommendations and asserted that NRC has taken relevant actions.
Recommendations for Executive Action
Status: Closed - Implemented
Comments: NRC has performed inspections to assess the groundwater protection programs of nuclear power plant licensees and has reviewed options to potentially revise the overall regulatory approach to groundwater protection. Specifically, in 2011, NRC performed inspections across all 65 nuclear power plant sites to determine whether licensees had implemented, through the industry Groundwater Protection Initiative, the necessary procedures and processes to respond to a leak or spill of radioactive material to groundwater. Later that year, NRC initiated follow-up inspections across the plant sites to determine whether licensees implemented the elements of their groundwater protection programs identified as incomplete in the original inspection. In addition, in 2012 based in part on our findings reported in GAO-11-563, NRC analyzed two options for the overall regulatory approach to groundwater protection: (1) continue the current regulatory approach, which includes regulatory requirements issued in a June 2011 final rule on decommissioning planning that requires licensees to perform soil and groundwater surveys to identify residual radioactive contamination, as well as continued inspections to monitor the effectiveness of industry initiatives; and (2) propose new rulemaking, which would require an analysis demonstrating that the cost to implement any new regulations would be justified by an increase the regulations would provide in overall protection of public health and safety. On May 24, 2012, the Commission voted to continue the current regulatory approach. We consider these actions sufficient to fulfill the intent of our recommendation.
Recommendation: To ensure the continued protection of the public's health and safety, the Chairman of NRC should direct agency staff to periodically evaluate the extent to which the industry's voluntary Groundwater Protection Initiative will result in prompt detection of leaks and, based upon these evaluations, determine whether the agency should expand its groundwater monitoring requirements.
Agency Affected: Nuclear Regulatory Commission
Status: Closed - Implemented
Comments: NRC has actively stayed abreast of industry research on strutural integrity testing technology through meetings with industry. As of March 2012, NRC had determined that the inspection technology was not yet sufficiently mature for routine application in nuclear power plant facilities, but in response to our recommendation, included a milestone in its November 2011 Buried Piping Action Plan to stay abreast of industry research and, when technology is feasible, analyze the costs and benefits of such tests. We consider these actions to fulfill our recommendation.
Recommendation: To ensure the continued protection of the public's health and safety, the Chairman of NRC should direct agency staff to stay abreast of ongoing industry research to develop technologies for structural integrity tests and, when they become feasible, analyze costs to licensees of implementing these tests compared with the likely benefits to public health and safety. Based on this analysis, NRC should determine whether it should expand licensees' inspection requirements to include structural integrity tests for safety-related underground piping.
Agency Affected: Nuclear Regulatory Commission