Federal Housing Finance Agency: Oversight of the Federal Home Loan Banks' Agricultural and Small Business Collateral Policies Could Be Improved
GAO-10-792
Published: Jul 20, 2010. Publicly Released: Aug 11, 2010.
Skip to Highlights
Highlights
The Federal Home Loan Bank System is a government-sponsored enterprise comprising 12 regionally-based Federal Home Loan Banks (FHLBank), the primary mission of which is to support housing finance and community and economic development. Each FHLBank makes loans (advances) to member financial institutions in its district, such as banks, which traditionally are secured by single-family mortgages. In 1999, the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) authorized FHLBanks to accept alternative forms of collateral, such as agricultural and small business loans, from small members. GAO was asked to assess (1) factors that may limit the use of alternative collateral; and (2) selected aspects of the Federal Housing Finance Agency's, (FHFA) related regulatory oversight practices. GAO reviewed FHLBank policies and FHFA documentation; and interviewed FHLBank and FHFA officials, and a nongeneralizable random sample of 30 small lenders likely to have significant levels of agricultural or small business loans in their portfolios.
Recommendations
Recommendations for Executive Action
| Agency Affected | Recommendation | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Housing Finance Agency | To help ensure that the FHLBanks' economic development mission-related activities include the appropriate use of alternative collateral, as provided for in GLBA, the Acting Director of FHFA should revise FHFA examination guidance to include requirements that its examiners periodically assess the FHLBanks' alternative collateral policies and practices, similar to the manner in which other forms of collateral, such as single-family mortgages, are assessed. Specifically, FHFA should revise its guidance to ensure that examiners periodically assess the FHLBanks' analytical basis for either (1) not accepting alternative collateral, or (2) establishing their haircuts and other risk-management policies for such collateral. |
In April 2011, FHFA issued Examiner Guidance Bulletin 2011-EGB-01 which states that commencing in 2011, the Division of Federal Home Loan Bank Regulation will review each Bank's outreach, lending, collateral, and risk management activities with respect to CFI members; and evaluate how the Banks address CFI member advance needs and support their CFI collateral risk management practices. The Guidance includes questions that examiners are to consider, at a minimum, in their assessment of the FHLBanks' CFI collateral polices and practices. Specifically, the guidance suggests that examiners evaluate the existence and appropriateness of the Bank's (1) decision to accept CFI collateral, (2) methods for validating and supporting its CFI collateral discounts; and (3) data sources used to evaluate loan delinquency, market liquidity, and current pricing conditions. With the issuance of 2011-EGB-01, FHFA has sufficiently implemented the recommendation to revise its examination guidance regarding FHLBanks' alternative collateral policies and practices.
|
| Federal Housing Finance Agency | To help ensure that the FHLBanks' economic development mission-related activities include the appropriate use of alternative collateral, as provided for in GLBA, the Acting Director of FHFA should enforce regulatory requirements that the FHLBanks' strategic business plans include quantitative performance goals for products related to agricultural and small business financing, including the use of alternative collateral as appropriate. |
According to FHFA's November 9, 2010 Advisory Bulletin (2010-AB-02), it re-emphasizes the requirements of Section 917.5 that an FHLBank's strategic plan establish quantitative performance goals for FHLBank products related to multifamily housing, small business, small farm, and small agri-business lending and report annually to the FHFA on its performance in achieving those goals. Beginning with the 2011 examination cycle, the Bulletin indicates that examiners will (1) evaluate the existence and appropriateness of quantitative performance goals for products related to agricultural and small business financing, including the use of alternative and appropriate collateral; and (2) monitor an FHLBank's outreach and Community Financial Institution collateral needs assessments efforts for safety and soundness and mission fulfillment purposes. FHFA has sufficiently implemented our recommendation through the Advisory Bulletin (2010-AB-02), which re-emphasizes the quantitative performance goals required in the FHLBank's strategic plans and includes an examiner's assessment of the FHLBanks' compliance with the requirement during examinations commencing in 2011.
|
| Federal Housing Finance Agency | To help ensure that the FHLBanks' economic development mission-related activities include the appropriate use of alternative collateral, as provided for in GLBA, the Acting Director of FHFA should consider requiring the FHLBanks, through a process of market analysis and consultations with stakeholders, to periodically identify and address agricultural and small business financing needs in their communities, including the use of alternative collateral. Such requirements could be established through revisions to FHFA's regulations for Targeted Community Development Plans or strategic business plans or through other measures as deemed appropriate. |
FHFA issued an Advisory Bulletin on November 9, 2010 (2010-AB-02) which sets forth the principles that FHFA will use in evaluating the FHLBanks' strategic plans. The Bulletin indicates that FHFA staff will look for whether the strategic plan (1) describes the FHLBank's current and projected future financial condition and risk level; (2) includes sufficient information to allow the FHLBank's senior management and board of directors to benchmark the progress of the FHLBank relative to the plan; and (3) enables an informed reader to determine whether the strategic plan is realistic, in keeping with the FHLBank's mission, and ensures the appropriate management of risk levels. The Bulletin also indicates that in developing the strategic plans, FHLBanks are also meeting the requirement to annually report to FHFA on their performance in achieving the quantitative performance goals for FHLBank products related to multifamily, small business, small farm, and small agri-business lending. FHFA has sufficiently implemented our recommendation through the Advisory Bulletin (2010-AB-02).
|
Full Report
GAO Contacts
Topics
Agricultural industryBank failuresBank loansBanking lawDocumentationFinancial institutionsLending institutionsLossesMortgage loansRisk assessmentRisk managementSmall business loansEconomic developmentHousingPolicies and procedures