Affordable Housing in Transit-Oriented Development: Key Practices Could Enhance Recent Collaboration Efforts between DOT-FTA and HUD
GAO-09-871
Published: Sep 09, 2009. Publicly Released: Sep 24, 2009.
Skip to Highlights
Highlights
The federal government has increasingly focused on linking affordable housing to transit-oriented developments--compact, walkable, mixed-use neighborhoods located near transit--through the Department of Housing and Urban Development's (HUD) housing programs and the Department of Transportation's (DOT) Federal Transit Administration's (FTA) transit programs. GAO was asked to review (1) what is known about how transit-oriented developments affect the availability of affordable housing; (2) how local, state, and federal agencies have worked to ensure that affordable housing is available in transit-oriented developments; and (3) the extent to which HUD and FTA have worked together to ensure that transportation and affordable housing objectives are integrated in transit-oriented developments. To address these issues, GAO reviewed relevant literature, conducted site visits, and interviewed agency officials.
Characteristics of transit-oriented developments can increase nearby land and housing values, however determining transit-oriented development's effects on the availability of affordable housing in these developments are complicated by a lack of direct research and data. Specifically, the presence of transit stations, retail, and other desirable amenities such as schools and parks generally increases land and housing values nearby. However, the extent to which land and housing values increase--or in the rare case, decrease--near a transit station depends on a number of characteristics, some of which are commonly found in transit-oriented developments. According to transit and housing stakeholders GAO spoke with, higher land and housing values have the potential to limit the availability of affordable housing near transit, but other factors--such as transit routing decisions and local commitment to affordable housing--can also affect availability. Few local, state, and federal programs are targeted to assisting local housing and transit providers develop affordable housing in transit-oriented developments. The few targeted programs that exist primarily focus on financial incentives that state and local agencies provide to developers if affordable housing is included in residential developments in transit-oriented developments. However, GAO found that housing developers who develop affordable housing in transit-oriented developments generally rely on local and state programs and policies that have incentives for developing affordable housing in any location. HUD and FTA programs allow local and state agencies to promote affordable housing near transit, but rarely provide direct incentives to target affordable housing in transit-oriented developments. Since 2005, HUD and FTA, and more recently DOT, have collaborated on three interagency efforts to promote affordable housing in transit-oriented developments including (1) an interagency agreement, (2) a HUD-FTA action plan, and (3) a new DOT-HUD partnership. While these interagency efforts have produced numerous strategies, local housing and transit officials told GAO that these strategies had little impact, in part, because they have yet to be implemented. However, the agencies have not yet developed a comprehensive, integrated plan to implement all efforts, and without such a plan, the agencies risk losing momentum. GAO has previously identified key practices that could enhance and sustain collaboration among federal agencies; when compared to these practices, GAO found that HUD, FTA, and DOT have taken some actions consistent with some of these practices--such as defining a common outcome. However, weaknesses in agency housing data and analytical transportation planning methods will limit these agencies' ability to effectively monitor, evaluate, and report results--another key collaboration practice. GAO found that other collaboration practices, such as establishing compatible policies and procedures, could be taken to strengthen
Recommendations
Recommendations for Executive Action
| Agency Affected | Recommendation | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Transit Administration | To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, the Secretary of Transportation should direct the Administrator of the Federal Transit Administration, and the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development should direct the appropriate program offices, to develop and publish an implementation plan for interagency efforts to promote affordable housing in transit-oriented developments, to include the HUD-FTA action plan and the Partnership for Sustainable Communities. This plan should include, but not be limited to, a project schedule, resource allocation, outreach measures, and a performance measurement strategy. |
In 2009, GAO found that since 2005, HUD and FTA, and more recently DOT, had collaborated on three interagency efforts to promote affordable housing in transit-oriented developments including (1) an interagency agreement, (2) a HUD-FTA action plan, and (3) a new DOT-HUD partnership. While these interagency efforts had produced numerous strategies, local housing and transit officials told GAO that these strategies had little impact, in part, because they have yet to be implemented. However, the agencies had not yet developed a comprehensive, integrated plan to implement all efforts, and without such a plan, the agencies risk losing momentum. To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, GAO recommended that FTA develop and publish an implementation plan for interagency efforts to promote affordable housing in transit-oriented developments. In 2013, GAO confirmed that in response, FTA (and HUD), published a "Work Plan" for their interagency efforts, as part of the larger Partnership for Sustainable Communities effort, of which both FTA and HUD were authors. The Work Plan included a project schedule and outreach measures. As a result, FTA and HUD's collaborative efforts were strengthened. For instance, due to these actions, the agencies were able to develop coordinated outreach and public events, targeted interagency initiatives such as a series of roundtable discussions, and propose and award a series of grants to transit-oriented development projects.
|
| Department of Housing and Urban Development | To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, the Secretary of Transportation should direct the Administrator of the Federal Transit Administration, and the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development should direct the appropriate program offices, to develop and publish an implementation plan for interagency efforts to promote affordable housing in transit-oriented developments, to include the HUD-FTA action plan and the Partnership for Sustainable Communities. This plan should include, but not be limited to, a project schedule, resource allocation, outreach measures, and a performance measurement strategy. |
In 2009, GAO found that since 2005, HUD and FTA, and more recently DOT, had collaborated on three interagency efforts to promote affordable housing in transit-oriented developments including (1) an interagency agreement, (2) a HUD-FTA action plan, and (3) a new DOT-HUD partnership. While these interagency efforts had produced numerous strategies, local housing and transit officials told GAO that these strategies had little impact, in part, because they have yet to be implemented. However, the agencies had not yet developed a comprehensive, integrated plan to implement all efforts, and without such a plan, the agencies risk losing momentum. To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, GAO recommended that HUD develop and publish an implementation plan for interagency efforts to promote affordable housing in transit-oriented developments. In 2013 GAO confirmed that in response, HUD (and FTA) published a "Work Plan" for their interagency efforts, as part of the larger Partnership for Sustainable Communities effort, of which both HUD and FTA were authors. The Work Plan included a project schedule and outreach measures. As a result, HUD and FTA's collaborative efforts were strengthened. For instance, due to these actions, the agencies were able to develop coordinated outreach and public events, targeted interagency initiatives such as a series of roundtable discussions, and propose and award a series of grants to transit-oriented development projects.
|
| Department of Housing and Urban Development | To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, the Secretary of Transportation should direct the Administrator of the Federal Transit Administration, and the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development should direct the appropriate program offices, to develop a plan to ensure that data collected on the various programs of the agencies related to affordable housing and transit are sufficient to measure the agencies' performance toward goals and outcomes established in the HUD-FTA action plan and the Partnership for Sustainable Communities. |
The federal government has increasingly focused on linking affordable housing to transit oriented developments-compact, walkable, mixed-use neighborhoods located near transit-through the Department of Housing and Urban Development's (HUD) housing programs and the Department of Transportation's (DOT) Federal Transit Administration's (FTA) transit programs. In 2009, GAO reported that HUD, FTA, and DOT had collaborated on interagency efforts to promote affordable housing in transit-oriented developments, including a HUD-FTA action plan and the Partnership for Sustainable Communities (PSC), a DOT-HUD effort. The HUD-FTA action plan calls for the joint HUD-FTA working group to develop performance measures and an associated management information system which, in part, would require that HUD and FTA determine if there are reliable data available for assessing the effectiveness of the results of joint actions taken by the two agencies. This is in line with a key practice to develop a mechanism to monitor, evaluate, and report results. However, the scarcity of reliable housing data and the limitations on transit modeling limits the ability of DOT, HUD, and FTA to determine whether current and future efforts are ensuring the availability of affordable housing in transit oriented developments. Without development of better data and data systems, the agencies will not have the information necessary to determine, among other things, whether they need to increase coordination or adjust existing strategies. As a result, GAO recommended that the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development direct appropriate program offices to develop a plan to ensure that data collected on the various programs of the agencies related to affordable housing and transit are sufficient to measure the agencies' performance toward goals and outcomes established in the HUD-FTA action plan and the Partnership for Sustainable Communities. In 2020, GAO confirmed that the PSC published several reports documenting its efforts and strategies to support communities and develop better data. For example, the PSC worked with United States Department of Agriculture to publish a report called Supporting Sustainable Rural Communities. This report documents several performance measures rural communities can use to track their progress and produce data that federal agencies can use to measure progress towards concrete outcomes and target agency resources. This and the other reports are indicative of a larger plan to improve agency performance and data collection efforts. In addition, the PSC put together resources to help improve data and performance metrics, such as an indicator webpage with descriptions and instructions for how to calculate various indicators. As a result of these efforts, HUD is better positioned to improve the data collected on its programs to measure the agency's performance towards its goals and outcomes, which was the intent of GAO's recommendation.
|
| Federal Transit Administration | To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, the Secretary of Transportation should direct the Administrator of the Federal Transit Administration, and the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development should direct the appropriate program offices, to develop a plan to ensure that data collected on the various programs of the agencies related to affordable housing and transit are sufficient to measure the agencies' performance toward goals and outcomes established in the HUD-FTA action plan and the Partnership for Sustainable Communities. |
The federal government has increasingly focused on linking affordable housing to transit oriented developments-compact, walkable, mixed-use neighborhoods located near transit-through the Department of Housing and Urban Development's (HUD) housing programs and the Department of Transportation's (DOT) Federal Transit Administration's (FTA) transit programs. In 2009, GAO reported that HUD, FTA, and DOT had collaborated on interagency efforts to promote affordable housing in transit-oriented developments, including a HUD-FTA action plan and the Partnership for Sustainable Communities (PSC), a DOT-HUD effort. The HUD-FTA action plan calls for the joint HUD-FTA working group to develop performance measures and an associated management information system which, in part, would require that HUD and FTA determine if there are reliable data available for assessing the effectiveness of the results of joint actions taken by the two agencies. This is in line with a key practice to develop a mechanism to monitor, evaluate, and report results. However, the scarcity of reliable housing data and the limitations on transit modeling limits the ability of DOT, HUD, and FTA to determine whether current and future efforts are ensuring the availability of affordable housing in transit oriented developments. Without development of better data and data systems, the agencies will not have the information necessary to determine, among other things, whether they need to increase coordination or adjust existing strategies. As a result, GAO recommended that the Secretary of Transportation should direct the Administrator of the Federal Transit Administration to direct appropriate program offices to develop a plan to ensure that data collected on the various programs of the agencies related to affordable housing and transit are sufficient to measure the agencies' performance toward goals and outcomes established in the HUD-FTA action plan and the Partnership for Sustainable Communities. In 2020, GAO confirmed that the PSC published several reports documenting its efforts and strategies to support communities and develop better data. For example, the PSC worked with United States Department of Agriculture to publish a report called Supporting Sustainable Rural Communities. This report documents several performance measures rural communities can use to track their progress and produce data that federal agencies can use to measure progress towards concrete outcomes and target agency resources. This and the other reports are indicative of a larger plan to improve agency performance and data collection efforts. In addition, the PSC put together resources to help improve data and performance metrics, such as an indicator webpage with descriptions and instructions for how to calculate various indicators. As a result of these efforts, HUD is better positioned to improve the data collected on its programs to measure the agency's performance towards its goals and outcomes, which was the intent of GAO's recommendation.
|
| Department of Housing and Urban Development | To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, the Secretary of Transportation should direct the Administrator of the Federal Transit Administration, and the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development should direct the appropriate program offices, to adopt a formal approach to encourage further collaboration in promoting affordable housing in transit-oriented developments. Such an approach could include establishing and implementing a written agreement to include defining and articulating a common outcome; establishing mutually reinforcing or joint strategies; identifying and addressing needs by leveraging resources; agreeing on agency roles and responsibilities; establishing compatible policies, procedures, and other means to operate across agency boundaries; reinforcing agency accountability for collaborative efforts through agency plans and reports; and reinforcing individual accountability for collaborative efforts through performance management systems. |
In 2009, GAO found that key practices for enhancing and sustaining collaboration could be used to help the agencies implement the HUD-FTA action plan and the recently announced Partnership for Sustainable Communities. GAO had reported before that federal agencies often face a range of barriers when they attempt to collaborate with other agencies, including missions that are not mutually reinforcing, concerns about protecting jurisdictions over missions and controls over resources, and incompatible procedures, processes, data, and computer systems. In an October 2005 report, GAO identified eight key practices federal agencies can undertake to overcome these barriers and enhance and sustain their collaborative efforts. While the specific ways in which agencies implement these practices may differ in light of the specific collaboration challenges each agency faces, GAO had previously recommended that federal agencies adopt a formal approach to encourage further collaboration. To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, GAO recommended that HUD adopt a formal approach to encourage further collaboration in promoting affordable housing in transit-oriented developments. In 2013, GAO confirms that HUD (and FTA) had embarked on "unprecedented" collaboration amongst themselves and other agencies working on promoting housing in transit-oriented developments. Each year since 2009, the agencies have prepared an annual set of priority activities for the Partnership for Sustainable Communities, integrated funds for competitive grant awards, reviewed grant applications jointly, created a formal leadership structure and held regular meetings on agency officials working on transit-oriented development, issued analysis of key issues jointly, prepared joint congressional testimony, and aligned their budget requests. As a result, HUD and FTA have strengthened their collaborative approach and provided a unified message to stakeholders in the transit-oriented development field. For instance, the shared Sustainable Communities web site has allowed citizens to observe all the agencies' joint collaborative efforts in one place and helped the agencies speak with one voice.
|
| Federal Transit Administration | To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, the Secretary of Transportation should direct the Administrator of the Federal Transit Administration, and the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development should direct the appropriate program offices, to adopt a formal approach to encourage further collaboration in promoting affordable housing in transit-oriented developments. Such an approach could include establishing and implementing a written agreement to include defining and articulating a common outcome; establishing mutually reinforcing or joint strategies; identifying and addressing needs by leveraging resources; agreeing on agency roles and responsibilities; establishing compatible policies, procedures, and other means to operate across agency boundaries; reinforcing agency accountability for collaborative efforts through agency plans and reports; and reinforcing individual accountability for collaborative efforts through performance management systems. |
In 2009, GAO found that key practices for enhancing and sustaining collaboration could be used to help the agencies implement the FTA-HUD action plan and the recently announced Partnership for Sustainable Communities. GAO had reported before that federal agencies often face a range of barriers when they attempt to collaborate with other agencies, including missions that are not mutually reinforcing, concerns about protecting jurisdictions over missions and controls over resources, and incompatible procedures, processes, data, and computer systems. In an October 2005 report, GAO identified eight key practices federal agencies can undertake to overcome these barriers and enhance and sustain their collaborative efforts. While the specific ways in which agencies implement these practices may differ in light of the specific collaboration challenges each agency faces, GAO had previously recommended that federal agencies adopt a formal approach to encourage further collaboration. To strengthen formal collaboration efforts, GAO recommended that FTA adopt a formal approach to encourage further collaboration in promoting affordable housing in transit-oriented developments. In 2013, GAO confirmed that FTA (and HUD) had embarked on "unprecedented" collaboration amongst themselves and other agencies working on promoting housing in transit-oriented developments. Each year since 2009, the agencies have prepared an annual set of priority activities for the Partnership for Sustainable Communities, integrated funds for competitive grant awards, reviewed grant applications jointly, created a formal leadership structure and held regular meetings on agency officials working on transit-oriented development, issued analysis of key issues jointly, prepared joint congressional testimony, and aligned their budget requests. As a result, FTA and HUD have strengthened their collaborative approach and provided a unified message to stakeholders in the transit-oriented development field. For instance, the shared Sustainable Communities web site has allowed citizens to observe all the agencies' joint collaborative efforts in one place and helped the agencies speak with one voice.
|
Full Report
GAO Contacts
David Wise
Public Inquiries
Topics
Best practicesData collectionFederal aid for housingHousingHousing constructionHousing programsIncome statisticsInteragency relationsLand managementLocal governmentsLow income housingMass transit fundingRegional planningRent subsidiesRental housingStrategic planningUrban development programsPolicies and proceduresFederal and state relations