Transparent Cost Estimates Needed to Support Passport Execution Fee Decisions
GAO-08-63: Published: Oct 10, 2007. Publicly Released: Nov 2, 2007.
As early as January 31, 2008, U.S. citizens will be required to present a passport or other approved document to enter the United States at all ports of entry. The Department of State (State) is developing a "passport card" as a means of establishing U.S. citizenship for individuals crossing U.S. land borders or arriving by sea from Canada, Mexico, the Caribbean, or Bermuda. State proposes to charge $45 for the card, which would include a $25 execution fee. Acceptance facilities, including State's passport offices, as well as post offices and state courts, execute passport applications on State's behalf, and retain this fee. GAO was asked to examine (1) the factors State considered when setting the proposed fee and (2) how execution cost data were developed. GAO reviewed current laws that authorize the setting of fees and met with State officials to determine how they set the execution fee. GAO also met with officials from State and the U.S. Postal Service (USPS) to discuss acceptance facility execution costs and how these costs were estimated.
State considered several factors, including congressional interest in having a low-cost travel document, when setting the proposed passport execution fee. State has proposed to reduce the current execution fee from $30 to $25, which would help the department to issue a lower cost passport card that meets the new documentation requirements. Consular officials told GAO that State made a commitment to Congress to issue a document that would be, at most, one-half the price of the current passport book, which costs $97 for first time, adult applicants. To do this, State needed to reduce its fees, including the execution fee. Consular officials stated that State did not want to reduce the execution fee below $25 because it wanted to recover its costs, which it estimated at $24.36 per execution. In addition, the fee needed to be high enough to avoid jeopardizing State's relationship with acceptance facilities, on which State depends to provide passport services. State concluded that $25 would compensate acceptance facilities based, in part, on data from USPS that initially indicated its passport execution costs were about $19, as well as a projected increase in application volume. USPS later told State that the $19 figure did not include additional indirect costs. GAO found that State's most recent cost of service study, which estimated passport execution costs, lacked documentation of key decisions. Rigorous documentation increases an estimate's credibility and helps support an organization's decision-making process. Documentation of cost estimates should explicitly identify the primary methods, calculations, results, and rationales or assumptions. State was not able to provide documentation of critical components of the study's methodology. For example, consular officials could not provide details of its survey used to estimate the time it takes to execute a passport, including how the data was used to arrive at the final time estimate. State has begun a new cost study that will provide updated estimates of execution costs.
- Review Pending
- Closed - implemented
- Closed - not implemented
Recommendation for Executive Action
Recommendation: To improve the transparency of the passport execution fee-setting process, the Secretary of State should instruct the department's contractor to provide additional documentation in its forthcoming fee study to support key methodologies, assumptions, and limitations. Such documentation should clarify survey and other work performed, disclose all sources of cost information being used, and identify potential limitations and uncertainties associated with the cost figures and other data. The study should also document the extent to which State's contractor incorporated estimated passport execution costs from USPS and other acceptance facilities.
Agency Affected: Department of State
Status: Closed - Implemented
Comments: In June 2009, State's Bureau of Consular Affairs published its cost of service study, which specifically addressed aspects of our recommendation. The 2009 study included an overview of the methodology, which documented various phases of the study such as the data collection method, data analysis, State?s time and activity survey, and data validation. The 2009 study also identified assumptions used in calculating passport unit costs, such holding constant--for fiscal years 2006 through 2008--the percentage of time allocated per passport execution activity provided by consular affairs employees through State's survey instrument, as well as limitations with State's survey instrument and data collected with that instrument. The study also documented the extent to which it incorporated estimated passport execution costs for acceptance agencies, such as USPS. For example, execution fee costs incurred by the acceptance facilities were assumed to be equal to the execution fee that acceptance facilities charged State, according to the 2009 study.