Skip to main content

Contract Management: Further Efforts Needed to Sustain VA's Progress in Purchasing Medical Products and Services

GAO-04-718 Published: Jun 22, 2004. Publicly Released: Jul 22, 2004.
Jump To:
Skip to Highlights

Highlights

The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) provides healthcare to millions of veterans at VA's medical centers and healthcare facilities across the country. To support veterans, VA manages a Federal Supply Schedule (FSS) program and a national contract program. Both use VA's sizeable buying power to provide VA and other federal agencies discounts on medical products and services. To cover its costs in running the FSS program, VA charges its customers a user fee. Although sales through VA's FSS and national contracts totaled almost $7 billion in fiscal year 2003, concerns have been raised about the efficiency of these contract programs. GAO was asked to determine whether the FSS and national contracts have provided medical products at favorable prices and to identify opportunities to improve purchasing practices and increase savings. GAO was also asked to determine if VA's user fee is sufficient to cover program cost.

Recommendations

Recommendations for Executive Action

Agency Affected Recommendation Status
Department of Veterans Affairs The Secretary of the Department of Veterans Affairs should explore opportunities to use its buying power to obtain more favorable prices for healthcare services.
Closed – Implemented
According to VHA, the Prosthetics and Clinical Logistics Office has developed a data warehouse that now has procurement history data from Fiscal Year 2006 to the present. Data from the database is used to produce reports on procurement and populate to management tools developed jointly with DOD. According to a VHA representative, the reports and tools allow VHA to monitor medical surgical spend and switch to lower cost contracts for medical surgical items. VHA currently uses this data report to develop requirements for integrated product teams to enable new FSS contracts. The products purchased under FSS contracts are used as the basis for VHA National Prime Vendor medical supply contracts to allow for increased cost savings and efficiencies. The Anesthesia Recordkeeping System requirements that were established by the VHA's standardization workgroup were in the solicitation process as of September 2008. VHA's actions, as described by its response to GAO, show that VHA has explored opportunities to use its buying power to obtain more favorable prices for health care services.
Department of Veterans Affairs The Secretary of the Department of Veterans Affairs should strengthen oversight to ensure medical centers use FSS and national contracts to get the best prices available.
Closed – Implemented
VA IL 09-02 mandates procedures for ensuring extensive oversight for all procurement activities. Essentially, IL 09-02 requires comprehensive reviews at more than one-level of the procurement activity to ensure compliance with all Federal and VA acquisition policies. Moreover, the review process established by IL 09-02 ensures that the best prices are obtained whether using a FSS or National Contract. As such, oversight has been strengthened to ensure medical centers are using FSS or National Contract to obtain the best prices. Additionally, the Secretary of Veterans Affairs has approved the establishment of a separate center with responsibility of enterprise-wide and standardized procurement approaches by creating the Strategic Acquisition Center within the Office of Acquisition and Logistics (OAL). This realignment is expected to take 18-24 months, and will advance the goals of this recommendation by ensuring consistent application of efficiencies gained through contracting.
Department of Veterans Affairs The Secretary of the Department of Veterans Affairs should identify the complete cost of the FSS program and reassess its user fee to determine if it needs to be adjusted.
Closed – Implemented
The most recent review of the IFF fee was performed in September 2007. The results of the review are documented in minutes to the September 17, 2007 Supply Fund Board meeting. The review documented the need to raise IFF from 0.25% to 0.50%. The IFF increase was estimated to raise an additional $30 million and was used to fund the following initiatives: (1) Implement Center for Acquisition Innovation - $13M (2) Hire new Attorneys to support Contracting - $3.5M (3) 2 VHA CLO Initiatives - $2.4M (Logistics Data Analysis Team for SAM & Contract Support for Supply Line Functional Equivalency Project) (5) Dunn & Bradstreet VA Subscription - $600,000 (6) Offset Anticipated Operating Loss - $10M The Supply Fund Board voted to approve the IFF rate increase. VA's internal approval process for fee changes: 1)OAL Program Office documents the need to change fee and proposes new fee to the Deputy Assistant Secretary (DAS) for Acquisition and Logistics through the Supply Fund Chief Financial Officer. 2)If DAS for Acquisition and Logistics approves the proposal, it is presented to the Supply Find Board of Directors. 3)Supply Fund Board of Directors approves or disapproves, which is documented in the meeting minutes. 4)Board-approved fees are implemented, as approved.

Full Report

GAO Contacts

Office of Public Affairs

Topics

User feesProperty and supply managementContract administrationContract costsService contractsProcurement practicesContract oversightMedical services ratesMedical suppliesFederal procurementDrugsFederal supply systemsHealth care cost controlMedical equipmentPrices and pricingAuditsVeterans hospitalsHealth care costsHealth care programsHealth care servicesDiscounts